RSS

A Willhelm Scream + The Swellers + The Stitch-Up

I won’t lie, as I made my way over to Club Soda for this particular round of performances; I made a somewhat mischievous promise to myself that I would hear no Ska music that evening. A lofty goal, given that the show was headlined by none other than Streetlight Manifesto, one of the most popular bands left in the floundering North American Ska scene. However, my interest in the show had absolutely nothing to do with upward guitar strumming or horn sections and had everything to do with the monstrous Bad Religion meets Dillinger Escape Plan sound of New Bedford, Massachusetts’ A Wilhelm Scream. I discovered the band almost four years ago with the release of their sophomore record as AWS, Ruiner (though it was their fourth as a band since they released two full lengths under the name Smackin’ Isaiah.) However, after a while they kinda fell under the radar both due to a long string of inactivity before their newest effort, 2007’s Career Suicide and their tendency to not only not headline very often, but end up as the token aggressive band on mainstream Ska tours like this one (the last time they were in Montreal they were opening for Less Than Jake in 2006.) However, after their riotous and highly distributed performance at The Fest VII in October, the band re-entered my life with a vengeance and I didn’t want to pass on yet another opportunity to see them, even if it meant having to deal with obnoxious Montreal Ska Kids…and oh, were their many of them…so many, in fact, that the show sold out in advance. I’ll never understand just how Ska has remained so popular specifically in Montreal when it pretty much lost face everywhere else in…well, the world (though I suspect local heroes The Planet Smashers and Montreal-based Stomp Records have something to do with it.) Now, while I love Big D and the Kids Table as much as the next guy, they’re pretty much the only Ska band I can still listen to without wanting to claw my ears off these days (and that probably has more to do with A) The City of Boston and B) Operation Ivy, than anything else.) 

Upon entering the packed show space I realized, to my chagrin, that the typical formula of “mainstream ska band with punk openers” wasn’t adhered to as much as I suspected with this tour, as openers The Stitch-Up were very much a young, three piece ska band (who, prior to the show, I was confusing with Ontario Emo quintet The Stick-Up who I now realize broke up three years ago.) Mercifully, since I showed up late, I was only subjected to about five minutes of upward guitar strumming and ironic ballads about the KKK adopting highways before their set ended…and at least there were no horns…so it was only a half-fail really.

Next up was Flint, Michigan’s The Swellers, an overly melodic hardcore act I’d been somewhat familiar with but had never actually seen. In short, I hadn’t missed much. While the band was relatively tight in terms of their musicianship, they were boring as all hell. It was almost as if the only records they ever heard with Thrice’s The Artist in the Ambulance and Lifetime’s Jersey’s Best Dancers, except they failed to understand what really made both those records so good and subsequently combined all of the annoying parts of both to form a band entirely dependent on unnecessary blast beats and overly melodic vocals. Not as terrible as I just made it sound, but not compelling in the least either. 

Which leads us to A Wilhelm Scream, who after their first song (a riotous rendition of the first single off Career Suicide, “The Horse”) made it clear that they are huge sufferers of “big venue syndrome.” Some bands really do not come across well in venues with a capacity larger than 500 (or in this case 400, really) and AWS are most certainly one of them. The intensity and drive is ultimately diluted by all the empty space, so while the dedicated fans beating the shit out of themselves in front of the stage certainly had a great time, my perch from just in front of the sound booth left much to be desired and I’m sure everyone behind me and on the balcony got even less of why the band was so good (though given the sea of Streetlight Manifesto shirts, I don’t think they cared either.)

Despite the space concerns, the band was still tight as all hell. I don’t think I’ve ever seen two guitarists employ so much finger tapping, to the point that the majority of the guitar parts involved very little actual strumming, though their bassist’s attempt to playfully do the same on his own instrument fell flat for me. While I strongly support bassists stepping out of the shadows and holding their own on stage (mostly since I am also a bassist), you gotta recognize the limitations of your instrument and work with it goddamnit! Stop trying to LOOK cool and BE cool. Hitting tracks off their last three records (the aforementioned Ruiner and Career Suicide as well as 2004’s Mute Print) like fan favorites (and by fan favorites I mean my favorites) “Killing It,” “Jaws 3 People 0” and “The Rip”, they managed to easily blow away most bands in the admittedly flimsy post-hardcore scene (Paint It Black and Converge notwithstanding.) If anything, they need to embrace that scene a little more instead of constantly opening for ska crowds who view them as a token act at best or just ignore them entirely, though playing The Fest for the first time was a step in the right direction. As much as I hate to admit it, a big part of being a successful musician is placement…if you’re playing for the wrong crowd in the wrong place then you just aren’t gonna live up to your full potential, but they’ve done pretty well for themselves up until now and will probably continue to do so, so more power to ‘em I guess.

When their set ended I briefly flirted with the idea of at least sticking around for Streetlight Manifesto’s first song just to see what the fuss was about, but as the crowd around me got drunker and even more obnoxious I realized that they were actually making me hate the band and the genre even more by association…and I have just a little too much hate in my life already, ya know?

 

 

Planet Smashers + The Creepshow

The odd thing about The Planet Smashers is that I know they're a great band and I know I'll enjoy the show, but I never go see them. My guess is that it’s been at least 6 years since the last time I saw them. The thing that sticks out in my memory about that last time is that it seemed like I and my friend were the only two people in the audience who weren't dancing. Well this time I was flying solo, so take a guess how many people there were standing still…

Me not dancing isn't anything against The Planet Smashers, they're awesome, it's just dancing doesn't make sense. In fact, I have to give them credit for getting the-number-of-people-that-fit-into-a-sold-out-Club-Soda to do something so ridiculous. It really is impressive. Out of all the bands that I've seen live (which is a lot) The Planet Smashers have, by far, the best ability to get the crowd moving…

Anyway, The Planet Smashers delivered exactly what they were expected to: a nice, deep set of pure fun. What they do, they do well and the only surprise I can think of was the relative youth of the crowd. For a band that’s been around for so long, where were all of the old fans? I guess no one listens to ska after 20…

As for openers The Creepshow, they were, you know, alright. The only really negative thing about them was the singer's lame stage banter. The keyboardist and bassist were both pretty funny though, it's too bad that the singer didn't leave the talking up to them - but being the hot chick of course she's going to be the face/voice of the band. As for what actually counts - the music, I have no complaints. Not being familiar with them, I was expecting them to sound somewhat… creepy (come on, they're called The Creepshow!), but they didn't. That was pretty surprising. I would have preferred some creepiness/darkness over their pure upbeat poppiness, but that's just me. Despite not being their target audience, I still didn’t mind standing there for the duration of their set.

 

 

Flogging Molly+ The Aggrolites + Dub Trio

Flogging Molly has a very large fan base, especially in Montreal. The concert was sold out mid-day  of the show and fans of this Irish punk band were lined up outside Metropolis an hour before doors were scheduled to open. Not only is Flogging Molly one of the most entertaining bands to see live, but they have this uncanny talent for picking the best opening bands. This year there were two very different bands that opened for good ol' Floggy and both were insanely good!

Dub Trio, their name couldn't be more different than their sound. Yes, there are three of them in the band but their sound is more metal than electronic and consists mainly of loud power chords. Needless to say they were awesome. These guys looked like they were really enjoying themselves on stage, almost as much as the crowd- who were shouting and dancing in the pit below.

Speaking of dancing, the venue was so packed for the show that there were absolutely no seats! The sitting area became the 'standing' area...not cool Metropolis, not cool.

Up next were The Aggrolites is a ska, reggae band.  Now, the entire week preceding the upcoming Floggy show all anyone talked about was how this really awesome band were opening for Flogging Molly. So I was very curious as to whether or not these guys could live up to their reputation. They did and the crowd went mad. They were crowd surfing, dancing, screaming and singing along.

So far, this concert was the best I'd been to all year and I didn't think it would get better but it did thanks to Flogging Molly.

 I've seen the band before and they didn’t disappoint, but this year they were amazing! The entire band was on that night, slightly drunk and all the more fun. Frontman Dave King  is living proof that age doesn’t really matter. This guy is an energy drink… he boozed he shmoozed, sang and danced. Hell he even did a jig! (no joke) It was great. Flogging Molly is one of those ageless bands that gets better every year.

So get yer flog on and try and catch these guys the next time they're in town. It’ll make you happy. Seriously.

 

 

Street Dogs+ Hostage Life + Ashers

This is the fifth time I’ve attempted to begin this Street Dogs review with some kinda hyperbolic statement about how the show blew my mind and how Foufs is the perfect venue for a punk show and how the Street Dogs revolutionize street punk in 2009 but really? Who wants to read that? Not every show has to be mind-blowing or revolutionary to be good, and believe you me, this show was GOOD…except for one teency little programming snag.

Until about two days prior to the show, Boston’s own Ashers were set to play second as direct support for the Street Dogs while the show was to be opened by Toronto’s Hostage Life. However, once (the crazy cool) Shawna G and I made it to the venue we were greeted with two things I wasn’t expecting: one, a list of set times that put Ashers on first and two, an almost empty second floor of Foufs. By the time Ashers, who feature the legendary Mark Unseen (of Boston street punk monsters The Unseen) on vocals took the stage the numbers in the place weren’t much better, leaving the band to play to a nearly empty room. Now, this is only unfortunate since Ashers were DAMN decent. Blending punk rock with a semi-classic southern rock twang (which is funny given where they’re actually from), the only downside to the whole ordeal is that Unseen’s vocal stylings are SO unique that the similarities between Ashers and The Unseen are almost undeniable. Which is sad since the band really does have a more or less unique sound, even within the notoriously generic street punk genre, but they’ll always just be “Mark Unseen’s Other Band.”  

Up next was the aforementioned Street Dogs…I mean Hostage Life. These Toronto punks, while well meaning (evidently), were just way too similar to the headliners they were warming the room up for that I couldn’t even begin to take them seriously.  

Finally, the mighty Street Dogs took the stage. For those unfamiliar with the history of this band, they’re fronted by Mr. Mike McColgan, who was the original singer for some band no one has heard of called The Dropkick Murphys. After leaving the Murphys to spend time as a Boston City Firefighter, McColgan returned to music along with former Bruisers bassist Johnny Rioux and a motley assortment of Boston punks to form the Street Dogs. Over the past six years the band has released four full lengths and toured the world numerous times over. That having been said, while they’ve been to Montreal numerous times as part of bigger tours, this evening's show was their first headlining gig in the city and they wasted no time showing Montreal what they can do when the night is theirs. Much to my surprise, the vast majority of the set list was drawn from their much beloved 2005 sophomore release Back to the World including this writer’s personal favorite, “In Defense of Dorchester”. Leaving no corner untouched, they hit tracks from all four of their major releases including the rarely heard “Stand Up” from 2003’s Savin Hill, their latest single “Two Angry Kids” off 2008’s State of Grace and what can easily be described as one of the best punk rock anthems of the last ten years, “Not Without a Purpose” off 2006’s Fading American Dream.

As I said before, this show was not groundbreaking. The Street Dogs don’t revolutionize and re-invent the genre in any way, shape or form…but my God do they run with it well. In this day and age when a lot of new bands are clinging to the fad-aspects of the genre, it’s nice to see a band that actually gets what punk rock should be (and while it’s still uncertain whether it SHOULD be anything in particular…I’m fairly certain the groove the Street Dogs have is it.) Tight as all hell, pouring their hearts into every note and showing the new kids how it’s done. You really can’t ask for much more than that.

 

 

World/Inferno Friendship Society

Wasting no time on hyperbole, I’m just gonna jump right to the quotable: The World/Inferno Friendship Society skirt the line between innovation and outright inspiration and their entirely unique brand of orchestral, cabaret proto-punk may very well bring new life to a genre rife with cliché and stale personalities (and if you disagree you are wrong.)

Being an Inferno fan for quite some time now, I was more than a little stoked to hear they would be making the trip up to Montreal to finally play the city (and indeed Canada proper) for the first time in the band’s 13 year history. That having been said, I still did not know what to expect. Having seen the band three times before this (each time with a slightly different version of their constantly evolving lineup), I could safely make the claim that much of the magic of a World/Inferno show comes not just from what happens on stage, but the interplay between performer and audience. For those not in the know, there really is no such thing as a casual World/Inferno fan. If you don’t hate them then you fucking LOVE them and express that love by acting incredibly stupid (in the best meaning of the word possible) while in their presence. I would go so far as to say that the band not only encourages this, but bases their career on the unity and love shown by their fans (evident in, if nothing else, their name.) However, my worry going in was that Montreal, a city that loves their punk rock but at the same time doesn’t really allow for all that much innovation in said punk rock, might see a piano and a horn section and immediately call it “gay” (or worse, “ska”) and move on sight unseen and sound unheard. Without the intensity and backup of the crowd to compliment the intensity and creative energy of the band, would the Inferno translate as well live?

Turns out my worries were only half accurate: indeed, there were very few Montrealers present at Petit Campus that night (and a decent chunk of them were IN local openers, friends of CJLO and all around solid dudes Winslow or part of Team Winslow on the whole.) However, the true intensity and devotion of the average Inferno fan was a concept I had not considered in my predictions and by the time the band took the stage the dance floor was respectfully filled with some fine folk with entirely too much time on their hands from the band’s native New York (and a few unfortunate souls from Jersey), making the show itself seem just populated enough. Lead by the enigmatic Jack Terricloth, the slightly smaller than usual line-up (only seven members as opposed to the usual nine or ten, including new drummer and similarly solid dude Brian Viglione, formerly of The Dresden Dolls) took the stage and lead the audience in the traditional recitation of the band’s name before launching into long time Inferno set opener “Tattoos Fade.”

What followed was a full hour and a half of new material peppered with Inferno classics. While the majority of the set was made up of this new material, the band still found the time for fan favorite “hits” such as “Just The Best Party”, “The Brother of the Mayor of Bridgewater”, “Zen and the Art of Breaking Everything In This Room” and “Heart Attack ‘64”. Worthy of note is the fact that the majority of the new stuff featured Terricloth on a rather beat up but still functional acoustic guitar, which brought a smile to the face of THIS Sticks and Stones fan (if you aren’t familiar with Sticks and Stones and Terricloth’s role in it than you have some homework to do…trust me, you won’t regret it.)

While the band very much functions as a unit and includes many powerful musical minds, it really is the Jack Terricloth show and as a front man he has no equal (except maybe Eugene Hutz and even then it’d be close with Jack ultimately coming out on top.) Dressed in his usual custom suit and swilling red wine, he drew his audience in and enthralled them with stories of his three favorite things: money, drugs and sex and his interactions with them over his deceptively long life (which is the nice way of saying he’s fucking old…but as he says, punks age incredibly well.) It’s really difficult to listen to his words and NOT be inspired by his sincerity and mystique. While introducing one of the aforementioned new tracks he pointed out that one should never let a silly thing like the truth get in the way of a good story and just like that I had a new mantra to base my life on.

More a family reunion than a concert, a cultic ceremonial performance than a punk rock show, the band left the stage that night promising this may have been their first show here, but it certainly would not be the last. I’d say I’ll wait with baited breath for their return, but having them come to me is simply a convenience and by no means a prerequisite…I’ll probably be “that guy from Montreal at the World/Inferno show decidedly NOT in Montreal” for years to come (and I wouldn’t have it any other way.)

Cheers.   

 


Nomeansno + The Devices + Grand Trine

Of all the musical pairings I've seen on Montreal stages these past few years, not many have been as inspired as this one: a collision of two of Canada's most enduring punk bands, both of whom have a penchant for twisted humor and social commentary - and surprisingly labyrinthine tunes. With the unenviable task of opening up for two long-standing punk institutions, locals Grand Trine did the sensible thing: they kept it short. They couldn't have been on longer than 15 minutes, and that was about the right timeframe in which to best showcase their brand of indistinct-but-fun scuzzy punk.

Rick Trembles and his self-proclaimed "idiot cards" heralded the Devices' surprisingly meaty opening set, complete with the self-denigrating witticisms you'd expect ("I'm numb in more ways than two!") as he and Rob LaBelle went back and forth assuming vocal duties. The Devices have an appealingly slippery sound, less reliant on blitzkrieg distortion than on unpredictable songwriting and twin-guitar dynamics. I'll admit to being more partial to Trembles material, but LaBelle's songs were solid. I find it a little odd that the 'Devices seem to be utter unknowns outside of the province, and aren't terribly high-profile even here, considering their long history and Trembles' local profile as the Motion Picture Purgatory guy. If you've got any interest in Montreal's punk scene and you haven't checked them out yet, there's something wrong with you.

Of course, the main event was  NoMeansNo themselves. I'll confess that the moment Rob and John Wright and Tom Holliston came onstage, all I could think was, "damn, they're old." (Jonathan Cummins notes in his weekly column that they appeared like elder statesman even in the mid-80s). Sure enough, John sat down at his kit, set up on stage right, and bellowed, "we're...oooold," before launching into a massive, lurching new tune called, you guessed it, "Old", which was reminiscent of Wrong's epic closing track "I Am Wrong", all bass hooks and slow crunch. It wasn't the only new material to be played (we also got a memorable airing of a catchy new tune entitled "Liberation"), but it was the tone-setter, establishing their dark sense of humor and devotion to cranking out challenging, bracing material. Most corners of their discography were covered, from their mid-80s origins all the way to 2006's heavily represented All Roads Lead to Ausfahrt. Highlights included an incredible rendition of "Everyday I Start to Ooze," which had the pit swerving and skanking with great fury, the hardcore blast of "Oh No! Bruno!" (expertly placed immediately following the noisy crawl of "Old" for maximum impact), a solid rendition of "Humans" (which kicks off my favorite NMN release, The Worldhood of the World, which was otherwise absent) and a predictably awesome version of an old staple, the hard funk workout of "Rags and Bones".

It wasn't exactly an ideal setlist in my book - a little too much reliance on early, abstract material as well as a few too many of Ausfahrt's lesser tunes (never been a huge fan of "Heaven is the Dust..."), but with a back catalog so vast it's difficult to complain. Regardless, these old-timers wiped the floor with whatever young upstarts you spent your money on instead.

 

Propaghandi + Strike Anywhere + Humanifesto

Now let me just start this review by saying I was slightly worried while going in to the latest Montreal appearance from Manitoba’s Propagandhi (and that worry had nothing to do with the overzealous bouncer at Club Soda taking the batteries out of my portable recorder for fear that I would bootleg the show…although I was then half inclined to go buy new batteries and bootleg it on principle…but that’s neither here nor there.) Rather, in the months leading up to the show I experienced the following interaction more times than I can count with dudes who were wearing polo shirts: “you like punk rock?! Dude have you heard the new Propagandhi (pronounced “propaGANDI” as most French Canadians are wont to do) record?!?!” Now, don’t get me wrong: I love Propagandhi…I love what they stand for, I love the way they go about getting their message across (living entirely within the harder void of melodic-hardcore) and I cannot deny the impact they have had on the North American punk and hardcore scene throughout the course of their over 20 year history (specifically in Canada.)

However, (again, specifically in Canada) they are in every sense of the term “that band.” The band that every poseur who likes to fancy themselves a rebel gravitates to because, if I had to guess, they are loud and swear a lot (this is what Rage Against the Machine was in the 90s and Anti-Flag is in the U.S. now.) Therefore, I was expecting the usual Montreal almost-but-kinda mainstream punk show audience: guys in polo shirts who understand zero English, swilling Heineken with their buddies and frequently forgetting they aren’t at a hockey game and their loud and equally francophone girlfriends. Generally, shows like this make me want to commit poseur genocide. Were it not for CJLOs own Brian Hastie and his manservant Alexander keeping me distracted and the promise of what was sure to be an excellent opening set from Richmond, Virginia’s Strike Anywhere, I very well might have.

Speaking of distractions, while checking out the mass amount of activist propaganda the band brought on tour with them, I heard a charging drum beat coming from the main room and remembered there were actually TWO openers on the bill. After making our way inside to gawk at Montreal’s own Humanifesto, we found ourselves back outside in search of pizza five minutes later. Overly nasal and lyrically contrived, I’m fairly certain the only reason these mooks were allowed to open the show was because of their name. Thumbs down.

Following some delicious pizza from our friends at “that-place-across-the-street-from-foufs” we made our way back inside for the band I was unquestionably the most excited to see: Strike Anywhere. Having been a fan of their politically charged street punk stylings for many years but not having seen them for over a year, I was jonesing for some sweet sweet almost southern-fried punk rock. In this regard, I was not disappointed: their slightly more than 30 minute set hit all the right marks with tracks from all three of their full lengths and their upcoming record out this October and all the requisite intensity and sincerity one would expect from one of the most earnest bands out there today. My problem was the fact that while the room was more than packed, only about ten or fifteen people (including Hastie and myself) really seemed to be into it, which only hammered home the disconnect between the material being put forward by the bands and the audience that had rolled up because they like it when people swear. Simply put: if you like Propagandhi for the right reasons (well crafted hardcore with a message sharp enough to cut through concrete) then you should like Strike Anywhere and if you don’t you are wrong.

Which I guess brings us to Propagandhi themselves. After a relatively earnest presentation by volunteers from the Rainforest Action Network (good kids…I felt for them slightly given that NO ONE gave a shit about what they had to say), the band took to the stage and the room exploded as a lot of now very drunk French Canadians finally got to punch something. I know the band opened with the title track of their latest release, Supporting Caste but I can honestly say I tuned out after that. While it’s probably the number one crime all music snobs commit, I finally let my disgust with the audience take over.  Even though I should be used to it by now, it still boggles my mind how so many people can be so absent minded. Here are some of the smartest, well versed punks the nation of Canada has to offer and I’d say only about 6% of those in attendance knew and appreciated what they had to say. Of the other 94%, I’d say give or take 50% didn’t understand the lyrics AT ALL (thanks language laws), and the other 50 just didn’t care and were there because the band was loud and swore a lot. I’ve often called the band the Canadian Anti-Flag and I’m gonna stick to my guns on that one. However, the comparison stems not from anything the band does themselves, but how people react to them. Now, the jury is still out on how I feel about the whole “throw political jargon at a bunch of blockheads and eventually one or two will get it” line of logic, but I will say that I see little point in laying this good shit out for a bunch of drunken assholes who will wake up the next morning and make zero changes to their lifestyle.

Or maybe I’m just an overly sentimental pseudo-activist with an axe to grind. Either way I just got you to read 960 words chock full of slanted ideas and musical elitism…I somehow think Chris Hannah would be proud.

 


Rise Against / Rancid + The Riverboat Gamblers

The constant, hours-long rain spell that befell Montreal did little to dampen the spirits of those who showed up for the Riverboat Gamblers/Rancid/Rise Against show at Parc Jean Drapeau, on Ile St. Helene. The crowd appeared to be predominantly youthful and seemed eager for the proceedings to start and jockeyed for position in front of the stage well before the start of the show.

The Riverboat Gamblers had the tough task of waking up a largely fed-up crowd with their brand of punk rock, pulling out multiple cuts from the newly-released Underneath The Owl. Tracks such as "Victory Lap" and "A Choppy Yet Sincere Apology" woke much of the crowd up as singer Mike Wiebe's version of a punk rock croon went to work, slowly turning a largely unanimated crowd into a slowly-swaying mass of partially-pleased concert-goers.

Rancid divided up their setlist between songs from their latest record, Let The Dominoes Fall, and songs from their extensive catalogue. Kicking things off with "Radio", off of 1993's Let's Go, the band's mixture of ska and street punk kept the crowd going through their 50 minute set. The midset trio of "Olympia, WA", "Salvation" and "Bloodclot" very clearly demonstrated why Rancid reached the level of popularity they've continued to maintain through the last decade-and-a-half. The band has the ability to craft songs that hint at pop sensibilities, covering them up with a healthy dose of punk rock chord progressions and gravel-throated singer Tim Armstrong's near-conversational delivery. These elements manage to win over fans by stepping over genres and grab equal doses of pop sheen and punk rock sensibility.

The band continued to roll out the hits ("Fall Back Down" from 2003's Indestructible, "Time Bomb" and "Maxwell Murder" from 1995's And Out Come The Wolves) as the crowd ate it up, enthused to hear something familiar. They capped things off with their biggest hit, "Ruby Soho", which had several rows of excited teenagers singing along, shrugging off the newest torrent of rain that fell from the skies.

The headliners took the stage a little after dark, kicking things off with "Ignition", from 2006's The Sufferer And The Witness. Following that, Rise Against's set was largely a carbon copy of their December 2008 CEPSUM performance, only transposed to an outdoor venue. The band played almost all of the hits (ignoring "Swing Life Away" while playing "Give It All", “Prayer of the Refuge" and all of the singles from the band's newest record, Appeal to Reason) and a selection of older songs from their four prior full-lengths. The band went through largely the same set, beat by beat, as the December show, playing the same songs in the same manner (moving into the acoustic portion of the show at about the same mark as well as closing with the same songs) and left little to surprise. The upside is that they were consistent; the downside is that it felt like they were consistently going through the motions.

As the show progressed and I realized that perhaps I was reliving the exact same show I had been witness to months ago, my mind began to wander and concern itself more with the context in which the music was presented and less with the concert before me.

Is the band's message being lost in the static of the pop-punk music that envelopes these songs? Can Rise Against truly consider themselves to be efficient messengers of the causes they support when they've progressively stream-lined their musical approach to the point where they receive extensive radio play and major backing from a large record company? It is a question with many tangents and variables, and is also the same problem that befalls many politically-active bands who outgrow their humble roots and branch off into something bigger, signing with a major record company and claiming to be fighting the machine from within.

This is also a question that also concerns itself with the integrity of a band which decides to, in the eyes of some, co-opt their very vision into something that can be sold as a mere commodity, to be enjoyed and used and tossed without a second glance at the actual lyrical content

Issues like this are of special concern to those involved in the discourse of punk rock (both consumers and producers), a discourse which concerns itself partially with the very notion of "selling out", that is to say going corporate and becoming a vessel for the society that punk rock bands largely fight to change through social action. This feeling of going with the flow is largely detrimental to the spirit of a lot of the work Rise Against has done in the past. Handing out plastic Rise Against-adorned bags to Warped Tour attendees (which occurred in 2006) gave me pause for thought and planted the seed of this very struggle in my head.

Watching the sea of kids (with the occasional older person popping out) sing along to every word singer Tim McIlrath put out there made me wonder if anyone was truly listening to the content of the words and not merely the melodies by which these words came out. It is a question that troubled me, and as the strains of closer "Ready to Fall" gave way to the usual post-concert lull, I felt like it would be one only time could answer.

 

 

Warped Tour

My admirably apt associate summed up the Warped Tour 2009 experience pretty well, so I won’t bore you with a second recounting of the day’s events. I also won’t bother with the obligatory “this was my sixth and last Warped Tour because I am OLD” spiel that encapsulated my reviews of the last two years of everyone’s favorite summer cash suck. Mostly since A) it probably isn’t and B) I’m not old...not yet, and in fact Warped Tour 2009 actually made me feel a lot younger than I’ve felt in a good long while (not like the jump from 15 to 22 is all that impressive…if I were 36 maybe that statement would mean more, but I’m gonna run with it.) 

When I was younger I held this naïve assumption that while laypeople like me could judge bands favorably or unfavorably, there was a general sense of unity amongst “bands.” As I grew older, I realized this is starkly not the case and in fact musicians have been waging war amongst themselves, usually over the entirely silly concept of “credibility”, much longer than I’ve been on this Earth. This elitism has been especially present on The Warped Tour over the past give or take seven years. While initially founded as a summer, carnival inspired punk and ska tour, the lineups rapidly expanded to include representatives from such esteemed genres as emo, screamo, metalcore or, essentially, whatever happened to be hot amongst vaguely alternative kids that year. As the lineups became more diverse, the war of legitimacy raged on as the purists took up arms against the new kids, the punks glued their mohawks ever higher and the scene kids combed their hair even further down their faces. 

Then came 2009…then came “crunk-core”…then came Brokencyde

Admittedly, for a self-proclaimed music culture scholar, I did not see this coming. Who could have thought the once mighty hip-hop would…even COULD pervade pop culture like this? Never in a million years did I expect to see screamo kids attempt to rhyme-scream (or worse, lip-sync) over poorly constructed dance club beats. Try as I may, I did not see “crunk-core” coming. Now, admittedly, while they may or may not have attained this moniker, I’ve more or less determined Albuquerque’s Brokencyde to be a figurehead of this movement. Respected British author and commentator Warren Ellis has called the band "a near-perfect snapshot of everything that’s shit about this point in the culture" and I for one see it as a pretty apt description of these four pretty boys, decked out with their hair neatly coiffed and their guyliner (did you know that’s what they were calling it now? I sure as hell didn’t) eloquently applied screaming about tits and ass and throwing the n-word around like it was Tennessee in the 1960s. Despite having confirmation by other bands on the tour that these marvelous pretty boys were actually LIP-SYNCHING on the goddamn WARPED TOUR, kids turned out in droves to see them as well similar (read: similarly horrible) acts Millionaires, 3OH3, I Set My Friends On Fire and Jeffree Star. One could be very quick to crucify tour founder and organizer Kevin Lyman for tarnishing the almost respectable name of the Warped Tour like this, some would say almost beyond repair. However, I for one understand that times are tough right now, and in order to stay afloat at all everyone, even the punk purists, have to acknowledge (not accept, but at least acknowledge) that changes have to be made. To Lyman’s credit, he did manage to pack in a noticeable amount of “respectable”, old school acts in the form of NoFX, Less Than Jake, Bad Religion, Flogging Molly, Anti-Flag, Big D and the Kids Table and earlier on the tour, The Bouncing Souls, to the point that the few screamo acts present (Chiodos, Silverstein and Underoath to name a few) almost seemed like the odd men out, sandwiched between trends long past and trends present (whether this signals the end of screamo in the mainstream remains to be seen.) 

However, this new shift in performers had some previously unforeseen results: the legitimacy bar, once incredibly high, plummeted to the point that it all but disappeared and if you played your own guitars and wrote (and sang) your own songs, you were immediately accepted over the likes of the lip-synching pretty boys and scantily clad showgirls. Never in a million years did I expect to see any member of Bad Religion use the word “friends” and “Alexisonfire” in the same sentence. I was legitimately stunned to observe the playful back and forth between NoFX and Underoath as presented by their merchandise (mentioned above), especially after the very bitter and very public feud that occurred the last time they were on the tour together. For the first time since I was fifteen years old I saw “bands” (in general) united against a common enemy, playing their hearts out for a cause they believed in against someone they perceived as a threat (and rightfully so to some extent.) 

Therefore, when Gallows frontman Frank Carter thanked the (substantial) audience for turning up to see them, you goddamn knew he meant it. Now, I know I promised not to retread the ground laid above, but I just have to take a moment to emphasize how fucking incredible Gallows were. I’ve said in the past that Gallows are at their entertainment peak when they are goddamn pissed off. This performance proved that what may previously have been intensity manifested by anger was now very much intensity motivated by love. Gallows, possibly more than any other band that I saw that day, were doing what they were doing because they legitimately loved to be doing it SPECIFICALLY in the face of some of the other acts on the tour. I’ve been fortunate enough to see Gallows four times now and while it’s already old hat for Frank, the elder Carter, to make his way into the pit to rough house with the crowd he very much saw himself as a part of, I was legitimately surprised to see usually reserved rhythm guitar player Steven Carter throw his guitar off and jump into the crowd smiling from ear to ear during the lead out of crowd favorite track “Orchestra of Wolves.” I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: believe the hype, Gallows are one of the best things going on in hardcore right now and they can only get bigger (and better) from here. 

Before I wrap up, I want to mention one more act who I can honestly say not only shook me right to the bone physically, but reaffirmed the power of music to me in general: Minnesota’s own P.O.S. One of only two hip-hop acts on the tour (which is generally one more than usual), his set happened to be conveniently placed right inside the eye of the torrential downpour the pummeled Ile St. Helene that day. However, despite the rain beating down and the aural onslaught of the Anti-Flag performance happening a new yards away threatening to tear him town, P.O.S. ventured down off the stage, his microphone wrapped in a towel, and sang his heart out for the few fans dedicated enough to stand in a circle in the middle of a downpour to see a rapper perform at the Warped Tour. Despite the noticeably biting pellets of rain beating down on me, threatening cell phone destruction and future sickness, I stood my ground, marveled by the performance of this very small fish in the this very big pond. 

So that’s that…another year, another Warped Tour. It’ll be interesting to see where the tour stands next year if the changes present this year are, as some are suspecting, only the beginning. Regardless, for a few brief hours I observed a glimmer of hope for honest, hard working musicians in a scene that is quickly growing away from them. What happens next is quite literally anyone’s guess, but chances are I’ll be around to document it (or at the very least ridicule it.)

Fake Problems

Around mid-to-late 2007, Florida’s own Against Me! were burning up the charts and landing on seemingly everybody and their mother’s “Best of 2007” lists with their major label debut New Wave. This sudden hotness of Florida’s folk-punk elite inevitably resulted in many assumptions (or accusations, depending on who you ask) as to who “the next Against Me!” would be. The forerunners of this ham-fisted contest were undeniably New Jersey’s The Gaslight Anthem and their fellow Floridians Fake Problems (and Texas’ O Pioneers who, despite being the closest to AM! sonically, was all but knocked out of the running in most circles…probably to everyone’s benefit.) However, as The Gaslight Anthem blew up to super stardom and guest appearances by Bruce Springsteen, Against Me! themselves kinda faded back to a manageable level of popularity (as flavours of the week tend to do) and “the next Against Me!” ended up becoming pretty unnecessary a goal. Which left Fake Problems in a rather interesting place as they went in to record their sophomore full length late last year. After their brief flirtation with stardom, this scrappy folk-punk quartet found themselves with very few expectations as to the music they create, which manifested in one of the most creative, lyrically driven and legitimately GOOD records seen this year, appropriately titled It’s Great to Be Alive. Taking a lot of chances and succeeding much more often than failing, the story of Fake Problems looked to finally be getting interesting now that they’d escaped the shadow of Tom Gabel.

However, that being said, their performance in Montreal on June 6th felt more like an interlude in that overall story. Much like the beloved Marvel Comics What If..? series sought to answer mind busters such as “what if Spider-Man’s Uncle Ben hadn’t been shot?”, this show also felt strangely familiar to a classic “What If”…in this case, “What If Casey Lee Wasn’t in Fake Problems?” 

I could be sappy and try to prove that every member of the band is equally important to the whole, but that would really be a lie. The backbone of Fake Problems is unquestionably vocalist/rhythm guitarist Chris Farren and lead guitarist Casey Lee. While both excellent dudes, bassist Derek Perry and drummer Sean Stevenson really are not as important to the overall whole. So, as the band took the stage with Casey nowhere to be seen (and later revealed to be back in Florida due to a family emergency) I quickly realized that I was in for an unconventional Fake Problems set. Armed with two touring musicians on trumpet and additional percussion respectively, the band admirably played through about 50 minutes of retooled material substituting horn and keyboard for Lee’s usual southern-fried guitar wailing.

While initially skeptical, I soon found myself wrapped up the unique qualities and nuances of the performance. The band was clearly out of their element and at times visually awkward, but they trudged on with the intensity and devotion I’ve come to expect from them. However, it was clear that they were struggling. Their older, more straightforward punk material was easy enough for them to get through and crowd pleasers “Sorry Okay Sorry Okay Sorry”, “Born & Raised”, “Crest on the Chest” and “How Far Our Bodies Go” came off without a hitch. However, the majority of the set was full of the more complex, fuller (and most importantly guitar heavy) tracks presented on It’s Great to Be Alive and while they tried their hardest, a keyboard intro to “The Dream Team” just doesn’t cut it. After this performance I wasn’t really surprised that they cancelled the remainder of their current tour not long after they left Montreal. Far from being a bad performance, I’m actually grateful I got to see it. While not as full or musically apt a performance, it was a stunning bit of proof as to why Fake Problems deserve all admiration that is heaped upon them. One man down and limping and they still took to the stage and still tried their hardest to make the relatively miniscule audience smile (less than a quarter of Underworld was filled that night), and for that they should be commended. 

So, what is Fake Problems without Casey Lee? Answer: not quite Fake Problems…but not quite nothing either.  

 

Pages